General

Clapping2

2009-08-10 19:47 UTC · Daiverd (#2)

If aliens landed at a lecture they'd be very confused about what's going on at the end. Why is it we strike our hands

together violently to indicate we're appreciative of what someone did? It's an odd thing, an arbitrary cultural act

that could have been just about anything. Slapping knees, howling, singing a song, all could have been the tradition

just as easily as clapping.

In a recent article in Esquire, Elwyn Simons, head of Duke University's Division of Fossil Primates, says "We don't

know know how far back it goes... but you don't find primates doing it unless they've been taught to do it. They do not

clap hands in the wild. It's not to applaud something. It's because they're frightened or want to call attention to

food".

Jay Fisher, a professor at Yale University, dates the custom to the 3rd century BC, where (Greek?) plays ended with a

request, plaudite, for the audience to clap.

Various cultures throughout history have had alternatives to clapping. The article mentions the Romans snapped their

fingers. I know, first hand, that Bruce Springsteen fans yell "Bruuuuuce" at his concerts, which to many people new to

his concerts, sounds exactly like people booing.

I also find it interesting, when I'm in the audience, to try and be the first person to clap. Often there's silence

when performances, or lectures, end, and whoever claps first can always start a good number of people clapping. It's a

strange phenomenon. Almost as strange as standing ovations.